Balancing progress and preservation: Environmental crisis in the Himalayas and Char Dham project

1024 683 Parvaiz Yousuf

The Himalayan mountain range is known for its mountains and wildlife worldwide. However, this beautiful mountain range is often affected by humans in one way or another, be it in Kashmir or any other part of the Himalayas. They have been impacted in one way or another. One example that can be given is the collapse of a tunnel in Uttarakhand.

Recently, upon the collapse of the tunnel, many people were stuck. From the sinking of Joshimath to storms and landslides, the area has to deal with a story that shows how dangerous it is to alter the Himalayas. Experts believe that the Char Dham National Highway Project is at the heart of this problem. It represents a more significant problem, which is how an unsustainable model of growth is hurting the Himalayan ecosystem. Let’s discuss more on the topic here.

Understanding the Char Dham National Highway Project

The Char Dham National Highway Project was started in 2016 with the good intention of making it easier to get to Kedarnath, Badrinath, Yamunotri, and Gangotri, all of which are important religious sites. Sadly, it has turned into a huge environmental disaster. There have been a lot of shocking mistakes, legal mismanagement, and a shocking lack of concern for established environmental standards in this huge project, which cost 12 billion rupees and covered 889 kilometers.

The project, which started as a way to make it easier for many pilgrims to go on their spiritual trips, has turned into a story of careless development that is doing terrible things to the Himalayan ecosystem. There have been a lot of mistakes in this project, which was supposed to bring people together. These mistakes started at the lawhouses where this was allowed. Although the Char Dham National Highway Project was planned with the best of intentions, it has now become a terrible example of what happens when growth doesn’t take environmental responsibility into account.

The Associated Legal and Environmental Norms

Concerns are raised about the project’s complicated legal path, as changes and uses of existing laws are seen to be easing its progress. Notably, the Supreme Court, which is supposed to protect environmental standards, was involved in letting people get around the need for environmental effect assessments for projects that go beyond 100 km. The clear lack of enforcement for following environmental rules shows a troubling truth: growth is valued more than preservation. Once more, the Char Dham National Highway Project shows a systemic flaw in which the need to protect the environment gives way to the economic growth rush.

How Forests Were Affected

The Char Dham National Highway Project has done a terrible amount of damage to the environment in the Himalayas. A huge area of about 600 hectares of valuable forest land has been cut down without any care. Moreover, the Lesser Himalayan Range has seen the cutting of over 56,000 trees. This living mountain range was already prone to collapse, but now that its natural defenses have been taken away, it is more vulnerable than ever. The Char Dham project’s ruthless growth, driven by an unwavering desire for progress, has turned once-forests into barren landscapes. This has created landslip zones that can cause huge human losses. Uttarakhand is known for its biodiversity, but this unchecked growth has left scars that can’t be fixed. The woods that have been cut down and lost their diverse wildlife are proof of environmental destruction done in the name of progress.

The constant throwing of trash into the Bhagirathi and Alaknanda rivers, which are thought to be the sources of the Ganga and the Yamuna, is also very bad for the environment. Getting rid of debris without thinking causes natural blockages. This changes the paths of these big rivers and poses a threat to northern India’s water security. The government’s silence clearly shows a lack of concern for the delicate balance that keeps these important river ecosystems alive. As these waterways cut through the Himalayas, their health is very important for both the areas they flow through and the millions of people who live downstream. Not addressing the effects of dumping trash shows a narrow-mindedness that threatens not only the balance of these rivers’ ecosystems but also the people who live along their banks.

Char Dham Railway Project Adding Fuel to the Fire

Along with the environmental problem that the Char Dham National Highway Project has caused, there is also the Rs.75,000 crore Char Dham Railway Project, which is also very big. With its large-scale building of many tunnels, this railway project worsens the already serious environmental problem in the Himalayas. What is most disturbing is that the unique geology of the area doesn’t seem to be taken into account—the tubes are still being built even though the ground is unstable.

Experts say that the constant tunnelling and the presence of hydroelectric power plants in the area caused Joshimath to sink terribly. This is a sad example of the environmental damage that has been caused. Unfortunately, the recent tunnel collapse near Barkot is not an isolated event. Instead, it is a sign of a more significant problem: unplanned growth in the unstable Himalayan terrain. The fact that both road and train projects are attacking the area in different ways shows how important it is to rethink development strategies. This happens when conservation is kept aside, and more priority is given to development.

Silkyara Tunnel Collapse and an Engineering Mess

The recent failure of the Silkyara tunnel is a powerful example of the systemic engineering chaos that comes with such huge projects. The fact that fragile rock forms were not considered during excavation shows that geologists have a lot to learn. This fundamental lack of knowledge not only highlights a major flaw in the planning stages but also makes us question the government’s dedication to managing the Himalayas’ complex geological landscape.

Over 70% of the job is already done, which is shockingly high. The damage is nothing short of extensive. This collapse is a scary sign of how the government is trying to control the dangerous Himalayan landscape. What started as an ambitious plan to improve connections has, unfortunately, turned into a monument to recklessness that needs to be looked at right away and fixed.

Preserving Uttarakhand’s Delicate Ecosystem

As the workers stuck in the Silkyara tunnel were successfully evacuated, it is important to think carefully about what the Char Dham projects mean for society as a whole. The linked disasters, exemplified by the tunnel collapse, tell a story that calls for a major reevaluation of current development policies. The long list of mistakes, the complicated web of legal manipulations, and the harsh environmental effects paint a clear picture of how important it is to grow these fragile areas sustainably. As the rescue operation went on, it provided a sombre background to the bigger story of unchecked progress in the Himalayas.

Uttarakhand’s fragile environment is often compared to a jewel in the Himalayas’ crown. We are now at a turning point that requires quick and strong actions to protect it. Even though the current Char Dham projects are causing damage to the environment, they should not just be seen as building projects. Instead, they should be seen as a key way to help people live in harmony with nature and technology. The same can be done in the Kashmir valley, which is also a part of the Himalayas and where similar projects have recently been completed. All future projects in the area should be guided by the lessons learned from the damage to the environment and the imbalances in the ecosystem.

It is very important to take a careful method where protecting Uttarakhand’s natural beauty comes before ease of access. This Himalayan state, with its unique biodiversity and fragile landscapes, calls for a big change in the way we think about growth. Because the Char Dham projects had bad effects, they should be the start of a new age of responsible development that protects Uttarakhand’s fragile ecosystems and keeps them alive for future generations. This way, this Himalayan gem will continue to shine brightly.

What Can Be Done to Avoid Such Problems?

A lot is needed to make sure that development in the fragile Himalayan region is environmentally responsible. Comprehensive Environmental Impact Assessments (EIA) must be used first and foremost. These require a careful examination of all projects, no matter how big they are or how they fit into bigger plans. This all-encompassing evaluation includes the combined effects of projects that are linked, which helps us fully understand how they affect the environment.

Getting rid of legal flaws becomes another important part. Tough rules need to be put in place to close the gaps that allow projects to break environmental rules. This will make sure that the best environmental standards are always followed. Local groups and environmental experts need to be involved in the decision-making process. This is called “community engagement.” Their deep knowledge of the area’s ecosystem is a key part of promoting long-lasting and regionally appropriate growth.

Also, adaptive engineering methods must be used to make sure that solutions fit the Himalayas’ unique geological features. To do this, slope vulnerability analyses must be done carefully, and engineering methods must be used that take into account natural elements that protect against landslides. Preservation efforts, such as reforestation programs and strong laws against illegal logging, are very important for reducing the damage caused by deforestation.

Similarly, river protection has become very important, and strict rules are needed to stop people from throwing trash into waterways without thinking. Complete plans must be made for getting rid of trash and protecting rivers. We also need to take into account how these actions will affect the region’s important water sources further down the line. At the same time, it is very important to make people aware of how fragile the environment is in the Himalayas.

Conclusion

In the face of the problems that climate change is causing around the world, the Himalayas need our attention. The unchecked ambitions for growth have already taken a toll on this beautiful piece of Himalayan land. A peaceful coexistence between development and nature should not just be a lofty goal but a guiding concept that is built into the future of the Himalayas. As we talk about the Himalayas, we must change the story of growth so that progress and protecting the Himalayan ecosystem are seen as the same thing. In this time of climate uncertainty, the Himalayas always remind us of responsible growth. Understanding and managing them properly would mean understanding Mother Nature and its core principles.

References 

https://frontline.thehindu.com/environment/the-tunnel-collapse-near-barkot-in-uttarakhand-points-at-the-glaring-flaws-of-the-char-dham-project/article67557424.ece#:~:text=The%20Char%20Dham%20National%20Highway,like%20the%20sinking%20of%20Joshimath.

https://www.hindustantimes.com/india-news/bypassing-of-environmental-nod-in-focus-after-uttarakhand-tunnel-collapse-101700851192546.html

https://www.deccanherald.com/india/uttarakhand/uttarakhand-tunnel-collapse-ecological-concerns-need-to-be-addressed-for-development-in-himalayas-say-experts-2769225

https://www.businesstoday.in/latest/in-focus/story/uttarakhand-tunnel-collapse-experts-flag-urgent-need-for-advanced-geological-surveys-406430-2023-11-20

https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/india/uttarakhand-tunnel-collapse-ecological-concerns-need-to-be-addressed-for-development-in-himalayas-say-experts/articleshow/105191039.cms

Parvaiz Yousuf

Parvaiz Yousuf is a PhD scholar in Ecology and Evolutionary Biology at James Cook University, Australia, where he has been awarded the prestigious JCU Postgraduate Research Scholarship for his studies. He is the author of the acclaimed book Birds of Jammu & Kashmir Including Ladakh and has conducted extensive research on birds and mammals at the Asola Bhati Wildlife Sanctuary in New Delhi in collaboration with the Wildlife Institute of India, Dehradun. In addition to his ecological research, he is a well-regarded science writer. Holding an MSc in Zoology from the Central University of Kashmir and knowledgeable in Search Engine Optimization (SEO), he contributes as a science journalist to various international publications, including Asian Scientist and Truly Curious. Since 2018, he has served as Director of the Wetland Research Centre at the Wildlife Conservation Fund YPJK. He has also published research in fields such as cancer biology and biochemistry in prestigious journals like Nature and the International Journal of Molecular Sciences, as well as in popular magazines like Science Reporter and BUCEROS (BNHS).

Author

Parvaiz Yousuf

Parvaiz Yousuf is a PhD scholar in Ecology and Evolutionary Biology at James Cook University, Australia, where he has been awarded the prestigious JCU Postgraduate Research Scholarship for his studies. He is the author of the acclaimed book Birds of Jammu & Kashmir Including Ladakh and has conducted extensive research on birds and mammals at the Asola Bhati Wildlife Sanctuary in New Delhi in collaboration with the Wildlife Institute of India, Dehradun. In addition to his ecological research, he is a well-regarded science writer. Holding an MSc in Zoology from the Central University of Kashmir and knowledgeable in Search Engine Optimization (SEO), he contributes as a science journalist to various international publications, including Asian Scientist and Truly Curious. Since 2018, he has served as Director of the Wetland Research Centre at the Wildlife Conservation Fund YPJK. He has also published research in fields such as cancer biology and biochemistry in prestigious journals like Nature and the International Journal of Molecular Sciences, as well as in popular magazines like Science Reporter and BUCEROS (BNHS).

More work by: Parvaiz Yousuf

Leave a Reply