Bakarwal migration’s impact on Dachigam National Park: Balancing tradition and conservation

951 618 Parvaiz Yousuf

The Kashmir Himalayas harbor a distinctive and rich ecosystem teeming with diverse flora and fauna. Renowned for its national parks, wildlife sanctuaries, and vibrant wildlife, the region, unfortunately, faces mounting anthropogenic pressure. A notable instance of this strain lies in the annual nomadic Bakarwal migration – a seasonal journey undertaken by the Bakarwal community, pastoral nomads who rely on livestock for their livelihood. This age-old migratory tradition has unfolded across centuries, leaving an indelible imprint on the ecological tapestry of the area.

Yet, the present era has brought to the fore a growing apprehension regarding the repercussions of this migration on the region’s national parks. In this discourse, we aim to delve into the essence of this migration, unravel its intricacies, and subsequently shed light on its ramifications for the delicate balance of our national parks’ ecosystems and the wildlife they harbor.

Understanding Bakarwal migration

The Bakarwals, a pastoral community, inhabit the mountainous terrain of Jammu and Kashmir, orchestrating a fascinating annual migration. This tradition involves guiding their herds of sheep and goats from the lowlands of J&K to the elevated reaches of the Kashmir Himalayas as the summer ushers in. As the snow-capped Himalayan peaks yield to the warmth and the grasslands at lower elevations turn arid, these resourceful animals journey to higher ground in pursuit of nourishing forage.

Embedded within the cultural fabric, the Bakarwals’ migratory path is steeped in history and familial legacy. Setting forth from the plains during the months of April or May, they embark on a traverse that concludes by late September or early October. Along this journey, they traverse through landscapes of breathtaking beauty, encompassing environmentally vital regions, including national parks and protected areas.

Of particular note is the significant intersection of their migratory route with Dachigam National Park (DNP), nestled in the Zabarwan Range of the Himalayas. Encompassing an expanse of approximately 141 square kilometers, this sanctuary boasts a rich tapestry of plant and animal life, further adorned by the presence of the critically endangered Kashmir Stag, or Hangul.

DNP’s fortunate geographic placement aligns it with the Bakarwals’ passage, yet this harmony is not without ecological consequences. The Bakarwals’ livestock graze upon the park’s pastures, triggering a process of vegetation depletion. The repercussions are profound and far-reaching, initiating a cascade effect that reverberates throughout the park’s intricate ecosystem.

Impact of grazing

Regarding the Bakarwals’ migration practices, a nuanced balance emerges between their livestock grazing and the preservation of the region’s ecology. While these nomadic shepherds are permitted to graze their herds within the Kashmiri mountains, specific regulations, upheld by the law and the Jammu and Kashmir wildlife authorities, prohibit their entry into Dachigam National Park (DNP). The park, singular in its role as a bastion for the Hangul, or Kashmir Stag, embodies an indispensable haven for the feeding, breeding, and overall survival of this critically endangered species.

With a mere 250 Hanguls remaining in the wild, DNP’s significance cannot be overstated, particularly in a landscape where other mountainous regions have undergone substantial disturbance, rendering their suitability for Hangul’s existence increasingly precarious. The Bakarwals’ livestock grazing, though rooted in tradition, exerts a considerable influence on the regional ecology. The continuous foraging of their flocks precipitates the depletion of vegetation, a phenomenon that resonates throughout the ecosystem’s intricate food chain.

Anchoring this issue is the stark reality of thousands of sheep infiltrating DNP’s core, effectively sweeping vast expanses of critical vegetation. This greenery is of pivotal import to Hangul and its progeny, which rely on a nutrient-rich diet, particularly during the demanding summer months. Altered vegetation dynamics consequently reverberate across the park’s fauna, jeopardizing the sustenance of various wildlife species that rely on the now-depleted resources.

Compounding this ecological challenge is the substantial presence of livestock within DNP. This coexistence is markedly unharmonious for the Hangul, a timid and sensitive creature that instinctively shies away from disturbances, including human activity and the commotion associated with large herds of sheep, goats, humans, and dogs.

The Bakarwals’ presence additionally ushers in direct interventions within the park’s ecosystem. Their practice of felling small trees using tools like axes, often driven by the need for warmth and protection from predators, serves to disrupt the natural equilibrium of the area. Tragically, fires kindled for self-preservation occasionally spiral out of control, engendering widespread destruction.

The repercussions of Bakarwals’ grazing extend beyond the immediate and are manifest in the form of soil erosion, a consequence of the persistent trampling by their livestock. This gradual soil degradation leads to its loosening, making it increasingly susceptible to being washed away during rainfall. The ensuing erosion profoundly impacts the ecosystem’s long-term vitality, compromising soil fertility and obstructing the growth of vital vegetation.

In essence, the intricate interplay between the Bakarwals’ age-old practices and the delicate ecological balance of Dachigam National Park underscores the imperative for well-considered interventions and sustainable coexistence strategies.

Balancing Bakarwal migration and ecosystem conservation in national parks

Recognizing the historical and integral role of Bakarwals in our society and their longstanding migratory tradition, it is imperative to address the impact of their seasonal movements on our national parks. A harmonious equilibrium must be achieved between the Bakarwals’ way of life and the imperative of ecosystem conservation.

One viable approach involves the regulation of Bakarwal grazing within Dachigam National Park (DNP). Although the convenience of traversing the core of DNP aids their journey to northern Kashmir, stringent measures should prohibit their entry, while alternate routes circumvent the park. This aligns with the fundamental principle that no individual, including Bakarwals, should access the core of a National Park, save for scientific or research purposes. In this endeavor, the J&K wildlife department, along with organizations like the Wildlife Conservation Fund (WCF), has taken strides to curb Bakarwal entry using anti-grazing units at key transit points such as Bathen, Sangri, Zawoora, Astanpora, Brein, and Nishat. Although progress has been made, the scale of Bakarwals’ movements necessitates a heightened and sustained effort to effectively safeguard the park from their intrusion.

Compounding the challenge is the diminishing expanse available for livestock grazing within the Kashmir Valley. To alleviate pressure on national parks, an innovative solution lies in the establishment of alternative grazing grounds outside these conservation areas. Collaboratively devised with the Bakarwals, these designated grazing zones would permit the continuation of their traditional practices while ensuring that the delicate regional ecology remains unharmed. This entails a significant responsibility on the part of the government to comprehensively address this issue, restrict Bakarwal access to core park areas, and ensure the availability of suitable alternative grazing areas.

A pivotal strategy revolves around educating and training the Bakarwals in sustainable grazing practices. This transformative approach would underscore the vital significance of preserving the ecological equilibrium of the region. Equipped with a profound understanding of the long-term consequences of unsustainable grazing, the Bakarwals can transition into guardians of the ecosystem, actively contributing to its preservation. Central to this education is the unequivocal prohibition of entering national parks, refraining from tree felling, and preventing uncontrolled fires. Regular interactions and guidance would cement the commitment of the Bakarwals to sustainable conservation practices, fortifying the delicate balance between tradition and environmental protection.

Recommendations

Beyond the aforementioned measures, several additional recommendations can be put forth to effectively address the challenges posed by the annual Bakarwal migration to our national parks.

Firstly, fostering an open and constructive dialogue between the Bakarwals and the pertinent authorities responsible for national park management emerges as a pivotal step. This dialogue must center on devising solutions that harmonize the Bakarwals’ needs with the imperative of ecosystem preservation. By facilitating this discourse, the Bakarwals can be vested as active participants in the decision-making process, thus emerging as key stakeholders in the broader conservation efforts aimed at safeguarding the region’s ecological balance.

A second vital recommendation involves the establishment of a comprehensive monitoring and evaluation framework, developed collaboratively with the Bakarwals. This framework would holistically gauge the impact of Bakarwals’ seasonal migration on various aspects such as vegetation, soil quality, and wildlife dynamics within the national parks. The insights derived from this system should play a pivotal role in informing and refining park management strategies, ensuring that the measures implemented are precisely tailored to address the specific challenges posed by Bakarwals’ movements.

Furthermore, acknowledging the collateral issue of traffic disruption due to Bakarwal migration assumes significance. The ensuing traffic congestions significantly impede the daily activities of local residents. To alleviate this concern, the government should meticulously devise a time-bound schedule for Bakarwals and their livestock to access roads during their migration. By restricting their movements to nighttime, a prudent traffic management approach can be realized, minimizing interruptions and ensuring a smoother transition for both the Bakarwals and the local populace.

In summary, these recommended steps, encompassing the facilitation of dialogue, the establishment of a comprehensive monitoring system, and the implementation of a judicious traffic management plan, collectively offer a holistic strategy to effectively mitigate the multifaceted impact of Bakarwal seasonal migration on our cherished national parks. By combining these efforts, a harmonious coexistence between the Bakarwals and the ecological integrity of the parks can be realized.

Conclusion

In summation, the Bakarwals play an integral role in the development and economy of Kashmir, sparing the need for substantial livestock imports. Their distinct identity is rooted in a centuries-old cultural practice of annual migrations through the Kashmir Himalayas. However, the coexistence of this tradition and the preservation of our national parks, housing crucial ecosystems, poses a complex challenge.

Achieving a delicate equilibrium is imperative; a balance between the Bakarwals’ requirements and the integrity of the park’s environment must be struck to mitigate their impact on these precious natural reserves. This necessitates a concerted effort encompassing measures like regulating Bakarwal presence and grazing within national parks, establishing alternative grazing zones, and fostering awareness about sustainable grazing practices.

By undertaking these proactive steps, the intrinsic harmony within our national parks can be preserved, safeguarding the rich tapestry of life they house. In this symbiotic approach, the continuation of Bakarwals’ seasonal migration can coalesce with the imperative of ecological conservation, ensuring a sustainable future for both these unique shepherds and the natural wonders they traverse.

References 

http://iskv.in/wp-content/themes/iskv/volume-pdfs/413376544d5b0871473f1a88272d7858pages_252-256.pdf

https://www.researchgate.net/publication/349117599_Seasonal_Migration_of_Gujjar_and_Bakarwal_Tribes_of_District_Rajouri_Jammu_Kashmir_and_its_Impact_on_their_Primary_level_Students

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bakarwal

Parvaiz Yousuf

Parvaiz Yousuf is a PhD scholar in Ecology and Evolutionary Biology at James Cook University, Australia, where he has been awarded the prestigious JCU Postgraduate Research Scholarship for his studies. He is the author of the acclaimed book Birds of Jammu & Kashmir Including Ladakh and has conducted extensive research on birds and mammals at the Asola Bhati Wildlife Sanctuary in New Delhi in collaboration with the Wildlife Institute of India, Dehradun. In addition to his ecological research, he is a well-regarded science writer. Holding an MSc in Zoology from the Central University of Kashmir and knowledgeable in Search Engine Optimization (SEO), he contributes as a science journalist to various international publications, including Asian Scientist and Truly Curious. Since 2018, he has served as Director of the Wetland Research Centre at the Wildlife Conservation Fund YPJK. He has also published research in fields such as cancer biology and biochemistry in prestigious journals like Nature and the International Journal of Molecular Sciences, as well as in popular magazines like Science Reporter and BUCEROS (BNHS).

Author

Parvaiz Yousuf

Parvaiz Yousuf is a PhD scholar in Ecology and Evolutionary Biology at James Cook University, Australia, where he has been awarded the prestigious JCU Postgraduate Research Scholarship for his studies. He is the author of the acclaimed book Birds of Jammu & Kashmir Including Ladakh and has conducted extensive research on birds and mammals at the Asola Bhati Wildlife Sanctuary in New Delhi in collaboration with the Wildlife Institute of India, Dehradun. In addition to his ecological research, he is a well-regarded science writer. Holding an MSc in Zoology from the Central University of Kashmir and knowledgeable in Search Engine Optimization (SEO), he contributes as a science journalist to various international publications, including Asian Scientist and Truly Curious. Since 2018, he has served as Director of the Wetland Research Centre at the Wildlife Conservation Fund YPJK. He has also published research in fields such as cancer biology and biochemistry in prestigious journals like Nature and the International Journal of Molecular Sciences, as well as in popular magazines like Science Reporter and BUCEROS (BNHS).

More work by: Parvaiz Yousuf

Leave a Reply